48 Comments
User's avatar
Howard Takiff's avatar

All conspiracy theory-type connections. No real evidence for lab leak has ever been found, and there is some real evidence for natural origin that has never by debunked. Saying that some isolates with incomplete sequence data were excluded doesn’t invalidate the analysis of those included. Would have been optimal if all isolates had analizable sequences, but that doesn’t negate the association of the isolates analyzed with the wet market and lack of any association with WIV. The unfunded grant was to DARPA, for Pentagon funding, so maybe questions should be directed at US biowarfaare facilities.

Alex Washburne, PhD's avatar

Here’s an article on forensic evidence: *any* items, substances, or information during an investigation that can either support or refute a case.

The DEFUSE grant is thus evidence - it is information that supports a case that the labs in Wuhan intended to make like SARS-CoV-2, as key features unique to SARS-CoV-2 are found in the 2018 DEFUSE grant that includes PIs from Wuhan.

So you see, your claims that there is “no evidence” are wrong. It’s possible once you update your understanding of the nature evidence, you could have something credible to say here, but your claims about the nature of evidence in general, and specifically about the evidence for a lab origin theory, are wrong.

https://www.aiu.edu/innovative/forensic-evidence/

Howard Takiff's avatar

even if the work was performed, for which there is no evidence, it is only relevant if they used a background virus extremely close to SARS 2, but this hasn’t been identified, so Defuse is 2 cow pies. You’re on a roll. Btw, did you come up with the concept of rating non evidence by your own opinion of its probability all by yourself? Are the real Dr. Cow Pie?

Alex Washburne, PhD's avatar

Based on the snark of your replies, I’m coming to the conclusion that you’re not seriously interested in answering this question, but rather bringing partisanship, polarization, and bias to social media in an effort to win arguments through toxicity. That doesn’t work for me, nor does it work for other serious people.

Howard Takiff's avatar

Find the skeleton in the closet.

Mike S's avatar

That’s not evidence, it’s correlative speculation. Simple analogy: If I claimed I wanted to shoot someone, and the next day that person was found shot, is my proposal evidence I shot them? No.

The DEFUSE proposal outlined inserting known cleavage sites into specific backbone viruses. The fact that cleavage sites were found is not evidence that the DEFUSE proposal was acted upon. Your logical flaw here is the “Affirming the consequent” fallacy.

And remember, SARS-CoV-2 has an entirely novel genetic backbone that differs by over 1,000 nucleotides from any virus documented in DEFUSE or WIV databases. A lab cannot engineer a virus without an existing viral "backbone" to modify.

Howard Takiff's avatar

Defuse wasn’t funded= Cow pie

Howard Takiff's avatar

Using your method, assigning arbitrary statistical possibilities to any piece of information has a fatal problem. Based on all previous pandemics— influenza (various), hiv, MERS, sars1, monkey pox, hantavirus etc. — being the result of spillover from an animal, the prior odds that sars2 is also a spillover are so great that they overwhelm the combined total probability of all the cow pies that are arbitrarily rated as probabilistically supporting a lab leak origin. Spillover probability is based on previous evidence. Lab leak probability is based on observer bias

Alex Washburne, PhD's avatar

You seem to not understand the nature of forensic evidence. There is considerable evidence of a lab origin, more than you know.

Howard Takiff's avatar

Cite the evidence please.

Alex Washburne, PhD's avatar

An old version, some new evidence has emerged (e.g. corroboration of reverse genetic system findings as DEFUSE grant contained order forms for BsmBI as well as specific proposals to insert a furin cleavage site at S1/S2 junction where it’s found in SARS-CoV-2).

https://alexwasburne.substack.com/p/the-case-for-a-lab-origin-of-sars

Howard Takiff's avatar

That’s not even circumstantial evidence. Please be serious.

Howard Takiff's avatar

Right, no one except conspiracy theorists accept your definition. Actually that definition essentially defines conspiracy theory

Alex Washburne, PhD's avatar

What is “evidence”? As someone who has worked in statistics and theoretical questions across scientific fields, this is the most important question for you to answer before we begin our next lesson.

Howard Takiff's avatar

Evidence is not a statistical construct. But to even get to your “consistency “ argument you have to invalidate real, quality evidence from the viral sequences of variants A and B. So you have to discard real evidence to make your nonevidence appear consistent. A perfect example of self deception.

Alex Washburne, PhD's avatar

You haven’t defined evidence still.

Howard Takiff's avatar

You want a better, juicier conspiracy theory (also with no evidence whatsoever): the virus was made at Ft. Detrick usamriid facility, which shut down in August 2019, allegedly for biosafety problems, but really to prepare the virus that the military took to Wuhan for the military Olympics in Wuhan in October 2019. In Wuhan, they spread the virus at the wet market to the raccoon dogs, who took it back to their breeding farm to spread in their colony. Raccoon dogs were regularly taken and sold at the market, allowing it to spread to humans.

Alex Washburne, PhD's avatar

There’s no evidence to support the claim that research capable of generating SARS-CoV-2 was being conducted or even proposed at Ft Detrick.

It was, however, proposed by a group that proposed very specific modifications and research in a BSL-2 environment in a very specific city:

Wuhan.

Most Americans believe it is a lab leak because they can see the obvious and don’t exist in the unfortunate silo academics have created for themselves. Even DOE, FBI, and CIA believe a lab origin is most likely - these are by far the most biologically expert branches of the US IC.

It’s up to you whether you want to advance your understanding of forensics and analysis to better understand this issue. I can lead a horse to evidence, I can’t make it think.

Howard Takiff's avatar

The U.S. sent about 360 military personnel to the games in Wuhan in October 2019. You didn’t know that, did you?

Alex Washburne, PhD's avatar

How many people from all over the world flew into Wuhan October 2019? Did any of them have proposals to insert a furin cleavage site in a bat SARS-related coronavirus reverse genetics system, with order forms for BsmBI, in 2018? Did any of them have the world’s largest stockpile of bat SARS-related coronaviruses and published research making chimeric coronaviruses on a novel reverse genetics system?

You’re bringing up red herrings. Your inability to make a steel man case for lab origin theory reveals the unfortunate silo you live in.

Howard Takiff's avatar

Yes there is, I saw the publications, but ever think bio weapons research might be extremely secret?

Alex Washburne, PhD's avatar

The US complies with the bioweapons convention. Many people harbor conspiracy theories that aliens are in Area 51 and such, but those have no evidence.

ODNI meanwhile assesses countries like Russia have active BW programs. The worst conspiracies are those that distrust the sincerity or underestimate the sophistication of the US intelligence community, its methods, its sources, and the trustworthiness of its assessments.

GeoffPainPhD's avatar

A patent for Weaponization of Coronavirus by insertion of the Furin Cleavage Site was lodged in 2002.

https://geoffpain.substack.com/p/pfizer-used-synthetic-life-derived